Skip to results Give me something toPlay

/

What to play next

Games like Sea of Thieves

2018PC · PS · Xbox

24 games that share what Sea of Thieves does well: sim, open world and pirates. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices as of Oct 16, 2026

Multiplayer
Green Hell
2019PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Online co-op, open world
Critics
78
Metacritic
Players
84%
Steam
To beat
~24h
IGDB
$2.50~~was $24.99~~−90%
In PS Plus
Multiplayer
Satisfactory
2024PC · PS · Xbox
Open world, co-op
Critics
91
Metacritic
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
~172h
IGDB
$37.99~~was $39.99~~−5%
Outer Wilds
2019PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Open world, first-person
Critics
85
Metacritic
Players
95%
Steam
To beat
~19h
IGDB
$12.49~~was $24.99~~−50%
Multiplayer
Borderlands 3
2019PC · PS · Xbox
FPS, online co-op
Critics
81
Metacritic
Players
81%
Steam
To beat
~42h
IGDB
$5.09~~was $59.99~~−92%
MultiplayerEarly access
Bellwright
2024PC · PS · Xbox
Online co-op, open world
Critics
unknown
Players
80%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$29.99
MultiplayerEarly access
Schedule I
2025PC
FPS, open world
Critics
unknown
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
~91h
IGDB
$19.99
Multiplayer
Forgotten Seas
2025PC
Sailing, pirates
Critics
unknown
Players
75%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$9.70~~was $24.99~~−61%
Multiplayer
Monster Hunter Wilds
2025PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Online co-op, open world
Critics
87
IGDB
Players
52%
Steam
To beat
~25h
IGDB
$26.95~~was $39.99~~−33%
Multiplayer
Garry's Mod
2004PC · Mac
PvP, FPS
Critics
unknown
Players
96%
Steam
To beat
200h+
IGDB
$9.99
Multiplayer
Stormworks: Build and Rescue
2020PC · Mac
Sailing, naval
Critics
unknown
Players
90%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$24.99
Multiplayer
Blackwake
2017PC · Mac
Sailing, naval
Critics
unknown
Players
80%
Steam
To beat
unknown
Free
Free to play
Multiplayer
Ranch Simulator
2023PC
Online co-op, open world
Critics
unknown
Players
79%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$24.99
Multiplayer
Ale & Tale Tavern
2024PC
Online co-op, co-op
Critics
unknown
Players
88%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$5.84~~was $14.99~~Historical low
Multiplayer
Ark: Survival Evolved
2017PC · Mac · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android
Open world, co-op
Critics
70
Metacritic
Players
83%
Steam
To beat
200h+
IGDB
$14.99
Multiplayer
Fantasy Life i: The Girl Who Steals Time
2025PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android
PvE, online co-op
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
~60h
IGDB
$59.99
Multiplayer
Raft
2022PC · PS · Xbox
Online co-op, open world
Critics
unknown
Players
93%
Steam
To beat
~27h
IGDB
$19.99
Multiplayer
Outbound
2026PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Online co-op, open world
Critics
unknown
Players
73%
Steam
To beat
~26h
IGDB
$24.99
In Game Pass
MultiplayerEarly access
Ships at Sea
2024PC
Sailing, naval
Critics
unknown
Players
69%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$13.74~~was $24.99~~−45%
Slime Rancher 2
2025PC · PS · Xbox
FPS, open world
Critics
unknown
Players
94%
Steam
To beat
~24h
IGDB
$24.84~~was $29.99~~−17%
Multiplayer
Steep
2016PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Open world, co-op
Critics
72
Metacritic
Players
82%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$26.99~~was $29.99~~−10%
In Game Pass · PS Plus · Ubisoft+
Multiplayer
Peak
2025PC
Online co-op, co-op
Critics
83
OpenCritic
Players
94%
Steam
To beat
~6h
IGDB
$6.24~~was $7.99~~−22%
Multiplayer
Tempest
2016PC · Mac
Sailing, naval
Critics
60
Metacritic
Players
69%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$3.44~~was $14.99~~−77%
Multiplayer
Scrap Mechanic
2026PC
Online co-op, open world
Critics
unknown
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
~50h
IGDB
$19.99
MultiplayerEarly access
World of Sea Battle
2025PC
Sailing, pirates
Critics
unknown
Players
75%
Steam
To beat
~30h
IGDB
Free
Free to play

Hidden gems like Sea of Thieves

Highly rated, under 5,000 Steam reviews, and outside the big series.

See all hidden gems

Proteus
2013 · PC · Mac
Open world, first-person
82% of 1,426 Steam reviews
$9.99
MultiplayerEarly access
Swords 'n Magic and Stuff
2020 · PC
Open world, exploration
92% of 890 Steam reviews
$22.39~~was $24.99~~−10%
Multiplayer
Occupy White Walls
2022 · PC
Online co-op, open world
92% of 1,334 Steam reviews
No price yet
Multiplayer
Viscera Cleanup Detail: Santa's Rampage
2013 · PC · Android
Online co-op, co-op
92% of 4,537 Steam reviews
$1.86~~was $2.49~~−25%
Multiplayer
Outpath
2023 · PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Online co-op, co-op
92% of 2,926 Steam reviews
$5.99~~was $14.99~~−60%
Rings of Saturn
2023 · PC · Mac
Open world, exploration
93% of 2,889 Steam reviews
$4.49~~was $9.99~~−55%