Madison
2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Psychological horror, Action-Adventure
- Players
- 87%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$34.99
What to play next
Games like Subliminal
2026PC · PS · Xbox
24 games that share what Subliminal does well: survival, horror and first-person. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it.
Tune these picks
Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.
24 picks · prices as of Oct 16, 2026
Hidden gem$9.74
was $12.99Historical low
Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location
2016PC · iOS
Mystery, psychological horror
- Players
- 90%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$7.99
Hidden gemThe Bridge Curse 2: The Extrication
2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Thriller, investigation
- Players
- 93%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$12.49
was $24.99−50%
$2.99
Hidden gemThe Cabin Factory
2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Immersive sim, realistic
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 90%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$2.99
Fears to Fathom: Ironbark Lookout
2023PC · PS
Thriller, realistic
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 92%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$9.99
$15.99
$14.99
$4.99
MultiplayerEscape the Backrooms
2025PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Dungeon crawling, psychological horror
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 90%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$6.99
was $9.99−30%In Game Pass
Who's at the Door?
2025PC · PS · Switch
Thriller, immersive sim
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 89%
- Steam
- To beat
- ~1h
- IGDB
$2.99
No price yet
Go Home Annie: An SCP Game
2024PC · PS · Xbox
Investigation, surreal
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 79%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$11.99
was $19.99Historical low
$17.49
was $34.99−50%
Welcome to the Game II
2018PC · Mac
Psychological horror, horror
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 84%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$9.99
Amnesia: The Dark Descent
2010PC · Mac · PS · Xbox · Switch
Surreal, psychological horror
- Players
- 95%
- Steam
- To beat
- ~10h
- IGDB
$3.99
was $19.99−80%
Hidden gem$19.99
The Exit 8
2023PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android
Immersive sim, surreal
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 92%
- Steam
- To beat
- ~2h
- IGDB
$3.99
In PS Plus
MultiplayerEarly accessBackrooms: Escape Together
2026PC · PS · Xbox
Realistic, psychological horror
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 88%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$9.99
Hidden gemEarly access$8.99
Emily Wants to Play
2015PC · Mac · PS · Xbox · iOS · Android
Psychological horror, horror
- Critics
- unknown
- Players
- 78%
- Steam
- To beat
- unknown
$3.73
was $4.99−25%
Hidden gem$4.99
Multiplayer$29.99
Hidden gems like Subliminal
Highly rated, under 5,000 Steam reviews, and outside the big series.
Saiko no Sutoka
2020 · PC · iOS · Android
Psychological horror, Action-Adventure
91% of 3,622 Steam reviews
$4.99
$7.99
Labyrinth of the Demon King
2025 · PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Dungeon crawling, psychological horror
92% of 2,128 Steam reviews
$12.09
was $19.99−40%
Is This Game Trying to Kill Me?
2024 · PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Investigation, mystery
95% of 1,524 Steam reviews
$14.99
$14.99
$14.99